Mechboards Discipline V1 vs sam Sesame Kit65% vs Alice DIY Keyboard Comparison

The core difference is the layout. The Discipline V1 is a standard 65% keyboard with a normal key stagger. The Sesame Kit uses an Alice layout, which is an ergonomic split design intended to promote a more natural typing posture.

No, both products are sold as DIY barebones kits. According to the vendor descriptions, they include the PCB, plates, electronic components, and hardware, but you must source your own mechanical switches and keycaps separately.

Both require soldering all through-hole components, including diodes and controllers, which is an intermediate task. The Sesame Kit's vendor page includes positive reviews from first-time builders, and both have linked build guides. The Sesame also includes pre-flashed controllers and labeled components, as noted in a review.

Yes, both keyboards support customization. The Discipline V1's description explicitly states QMK compatibility. A review for the Sesame Kit mentions it is very easy to remap keys using VIA, which is a graphical interface for QMK.

The Sesame Kit includes a switch plate and a bottom plate, both made from FR4 material. The vendor description for the Discipline V1 specifically warns that it does not come with a switch plate or foam, only a bottom PCB plate and acrylic cover.

No, both the Mechboards Discipline V1 and the sam Sesame Kit are wired-only keyboards, as indicated in their connectivity specifications.

The Discipline V1 kit includes a USB Type-C connector, as stated in its description. The Sesame Kit's description does not specify the USB type, so it is best to consult the build guide or vendor for confirmation.

The Alice layout uses a split spacebar and a unique bottom row, which may require specific keycaps or kits that support Alice/ergonomic layouts. A standard keycap set may not have all the correct sized modifiers.

The Discipline V1, with its standard 65% rectangular shape, is likely more compact and easier to fit into a carrying case than the wider, asymmetrical Alice layout of the Sesame Kit.

Soldering the components does not require programming. However, to change the keymap or layers, you will need to use QMK or VIA software. The Sesame Kit's review suggests VIA makes this process simple, and the Discipline's controller comes preflashed with a bootloader.

According to the vendor listing, the Sesame Kit includes the main PCB, an FR4 bottom plate, an FR4 switch plate, all electronic components, a pre-flashed controller, brass standoffs and screws, and an acrylic cover.