KeebFinder
Not sure which keyboard to choose? Try the Keyboard Finder now!

Compare KEEBD Lily58 vs Mechboards Lily58 Differences Side by Side

This comparison is for users deciding between two different approaches to the popular Lily58 split keyboard layout. The KEEBD version is a pre-assembled unit focused on wireless connectivity, while the Mechboards offering is a versatile kit with options for soldering or pre-soldered builds. The decision hinges on whether you prioritize an out-of-the-box wireless solution or a highly customizable project with features like RGB and OLED screens.

Lily58 Choc Assembled Keyboard
82
Lily58 Kit

Select a keyboard to compare

0.0 (0)
0.0 (0)
  • Released in 2024
  • Includes a No display
  • Supports Bluetooth, Wired, Wireless connectivity
  • Offers No RGB lighting
  • Released in 2021
  • Includes a Yes, OLED display
  • Connects via USB-C
  • Supports VIA configuration
  • Supports VIAL configuration
  • Supports Wired, Wired only connectivity
  • Made with a Steel, Plastic case
  • Features ABS keycaps
  • Offers Yes, Rgb RGB lighting
Scores
  • Performance: 39.4
  • Build Quality: 40.1
  • Productivity: 54
  • Customizability: 48
  • Portability: 82.5
Scores
  • Performance: 60.6
  • Build Quality: 79.7
  • Productivity: 65.1
  • Customizability: 87.8
  • Portability: 66.9
Name
KEEBD Lily58
Name
Mechboards Lily58
Release year
2024
Release year
2021
Switch Options
-
Switch Options
-
Profile
Normal Profile
Profile
Normal Profile
Hot Swappable
 
Hot Swappable
 
Layout Size
Other
Layout Size
Other
Layout Standard
ANSI
Layout Standard
ANSI
Layout Ergonomics
Split
Layout Ergonomics
Split
Knob Support
 
Knob Support
 
Display Support
 
Display Support
 
OLED
Mac/Win Support
 
Mac/Win Support
 
Multi-Media Keys
 
Multi-Media Keys
 
USB-C
 
USB-C
 
USB passthrough
 
USB passthrough
 
Connection
Bluetooth, Wired, Wireless
Connection
Wired, Wired only
Polling Rate
-
Polling Rate
-
Battery capacity
-
Battery capacity
-
Hall Effect Support
 
Hall Effect Support
 
QMK Support
 
QMK Support
 
VIA Support
 
VIA Support
 
VIAL Support
 
VIAL Support
 
N-Key Rollover
 
N-Key Rollover
 
Rapid Trigger
 
Rapid Trigger
 
Mount Style
-
Mount Style
-
Screw in Stabilizers
 
Screw in Stabilizers
 
Sound Dampening
 
Sound Dampening
 
Backlight
 
Backlight
 
Rgb
Case Colors
Case Colors
Case Material
-
Case Material
Steel, Plastic
Keycaps Material
-
Keycaps Material
ABS
Dimensions
-
Dimensions
-
Weight
-
Weight
-
*Something incorrect or missing? Please
let me know
!

Pros and Trade-offs

Your choice depends entirely on your willingness to build. For a turnkey, wireless-ready split keyboard, the KEEBD Lily58 is the straightforward option. If you enjoy building, customizing with lighting and screens, and want deeper software control, the Mechboards Lily58 kit provides superior value and flexibility, starting at a more accessible price.

KEEBD Lily58

  • +Pre-assembled and ready to use out of the box.
  • +Offers both Bluetooth wireless and wired connectivity options.
  • +Includes components for both wired and wireless configurations (e.g., sockets for different controllers, battery pads).
  • +Vendor promises ready-to-ship convenience without a long wait.
  • −Lacks RGB lighting or an OLED screen.
  • −Appears to be priced at a higher point than the base Mechboards kit.
  • −No mention of VIA or VIAL software support in its description.

Mechboards Lily58

  • +Offers extensive customization as a DIY kit with soldering and pre-soldered (R2G) options.
  • +Includes features like per-key RGB, underglow lighting, and OLED (or MIP/VIK TFT) screens.
  • +Explicitly supports VIA and VIAL configuration software for easy remapping.
  • +Comes with a variety of components like FR4 plates, acrylic bottoms, and sockets.
  • +Has a lower starting price point for the basic kit.
  • −Requires assembly and sourcing of switches, keycaps, and a USB-C cable for the basic kit.
  • −The wireless version is a separate kit and not a feature of all variants.
  • −The vendor warns that hotplugging TRRS cables while powered can cause permanent damage.

Which Keyboard Is Better for Your Needs?

The KEEBD Lily58 wins for office use and travel due to its pre-built nature and wireless connectivity. The Mechboards kit is the clear choice for modding and has advantages for programming and gaming due to its RGB, OLEDs, and robust software support. For content creation, the shared ergonomic layout makes them evenly matched, with the choice boiling down to a preference for wireless convenience or customizable displays.

GamingMechboards Lily58
  • •The Mechboards kit offers per-key RGB and underglow lighting, which some gamers prefer for aesthetics.
  • •Its listing mentions VIA and VIAL support for easy key remapping, useful for game macros.
  • •The KEEBD model lacks RGB lighting entirely.
OfficeKEEBD Lily58
  • •The KEEBD Lily58 is a pre-built, assembled keyboard, requiring no assembly for immediate office use.
  • •It features Bluetooth and wireless connectivity, reducing cable clutter on a desk.
  • •Its split ergonomic design can improve comfort during long typing sessions.
ProgrammingMechboards Lily58
  • •The Mechboards kit includes OLED screens, which can be programmed to display layer status or system info.
  • •It has explicit support for VIA and VIAL software, allowing for extensive layer and keymap customization crucial for coding workflows.
  • •The hotswap design supports both MX and Choc switch types for tuning typing feel.
TravelKEEBD Lily58
  • •The KEEBD model is a complete, pre-built unit, making it simpler to pack and use on the go.
  • •Its wireless Bluetooth functionality allows use without cables when traveling.
  • •The vendor description states it is 'ready to ship' and assembled, requiring no extra components.
ModdingMechboards Lily58
  • •The Mechboards kit is fundamentally a DIY project, offering soldering-required and pre-soldered (R2G) variants.
  • •It includes numerous components like FR4 plates, acrylic bottom plates, and sockets for extensive customization.
  • •Features like per-key RGB, underglow, and positions for rotary encoders are explicitly listed for modding.
  • •It supports both VIA and VIAL firmware for software-based modding.
Content CreationTie
  • •Both keyboards share the same split, ergonomic Lily58 layout which can reduce strain during long creative sessions.
  • •Both are hot-swappable, allowing creators to choose switches for their preferred tactile or linear feel.
  • •The KEEBD's wireless operation offers a cleaner setup, while the Mechboards' OLED screens could be useful for monitoring system stats.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Discover similar products

You might also like similar products in that price range:

100
$199
Chilkey ND104 CNC Aluminum Hotswap Wireless RGB Keyboard
Chilkey ND104
100%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Screen,
RGB,
Knob,
VIA,
QMK,
Alu case,
Plate Mount

79
$59
CIDOO ABM066 Alice Mechanical Keyboard
Cidoo ABM066 Alice
65%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Screen,
RGB,
Knob,
VIA,
Gasket Mount

96
$170
Nuphy GEM80 Barebones Keyboard Kit
Nuphy Gem80
80%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Wired,
RGB,
VIA,
QMK,
Alu case,
Gasket Mount

77
$59
CIDOO ABM081 Stellar Gasket Hot-swappable Mechanical Keyboard
Cidoo ABM081 Stellar
75%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Screen,
RGB,
VIA,
Alu case,
Gasket Mount

97
$239
Keychron Q10 Max (Alice Layout) QMK/VIA Wireless Custom Mechanical Keyboard
Keychron Q10 Max
75%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Wired,
RGB,
Knob,
VIA,
QMK,
Alu case,
Gasket Mount

74
$49
Qwertykeys Neo60 Core Keyboard
Qwertykeys Neo60 Core
60%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Wired,
VIA,
Alu case,
PCB Mount

96
$199
Keychron Q5 Max QMK/VIA Wireless Custom Mechanical Keyboard
Keychron Q5 Max
96%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Wired,
RGB,
Knob,
VIA,
QMK,
Alu case,
Gasket Mount

98
$44
Keychron V6 QMK Custom Mechanical Keyboard ISO Layout Collection
Keychron V6
100%,
Hotswap,
Wired,
RGB/ White LEDs,
Knob,
VIA,
QMK,
Tray Mount

98
$186
Keychron Q1 Max QMK/VIA Wireless Custom Mechanical Keyboard
Keychron Q1 Max
75%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Wired,
RGB,
Knob,
VIA,
QMK,
Alu case,
Gasket Mount

97
$44
Keychron V1 QMK Custom Mechanical Keyboard
Keychron V1
75%,
Hotswap,
Wired,
RGB/ White LEDs,
Knob,
VIA,
QMK,
Tray Mount