KeebFinder
Not sure which keyboard to choose? Try the Keyboard Finder now!

Compare Akko 5108S vs Keychron K17 Pro Differences Side by Side

This comparison is for buyers deciding between a traditional, themed full-size keyboard and a modern, feature-rich compact layout. The Akko 5108S offers a complete 108-key layout with a specific aesthetic, while the Keychron K17 Pro provides a 96% layout, wireless connectivity, and extensive customization through QMK/VIA. The decision hinges on whether you prioritize a dedicated numpad and a fixed theme or value portability, multi-device connectivity, and firmware-level programmability more.

64
Akko My Melody 5108S Mechanical Keyboard
88
Keychron K17 Pro QMK/VIA Wireless Custom Mechanical Keyboard

Select a keyboard to compare

0.0 (0)
5.0 (4)
  • Available in a 100% layout
  • Supports Wired, Wired only connectivity
  • Weighs about 1200 g
  • Sized at 41 x 442 x 132 mm
  • Made with a Aluminum case
  • Offers Yes, Rgb RGB lighting
  • Has Linear, Tactile, Clicky switch options
  • Features a low-profile design
  • Available in a 96% layout
  • Comes with a knob
  • Provides dedicated media keys
  • Supports QMK firmware
  • Supports VIA configuration
  • Uses a Tray Mount mounting style
  • Supports Bluetooth, Wired, Wireless connectivity
  • Runs at a 1000 Hz polling rate
  • Equipped with a 2000 mAh battery
  • Weighs about 679 g
  • Sized at 19 x 120 x 387 mm
  • Made with a Aluminum, Plastic, ABS case
  • Offers Yes, Rgb, White, North-face, Rgb North-face, White North-face RGB lighting
Scores
  • Performance: 76.3
  • Build Quality: 59
  • Productivity: 67.7
  • Customizability: 63.2
  • Portability: 45.5
Scores
  • Performance: 83.5
  • Build Quality: 81.6
  • Productivity: 86.9
  • Customizability: 92.6
  • Portability: 53.8
Name
Akko 5108S
Name
Keychron K17 Pro
Release year
2023
Release year
2023
Switch Options
-
Switch Options
Linear, Tactile, Clicky
Profile
Normal Profile
Profile
Low Profile
Hot Swappable
 
Hot Swappable
 
Layout Size
100%
Layout Size
96%
Layout Standard
ANSI
Layout Standard
ANSI
Layout Ergonomics
Normal
Layout Ergonomics
Normal
Knob Support
 
Knob Support
 
Display Support
 
Display Support
 
Mac/Win Support
 
Mac/Win Support
 
Multi-Media Keys
 
Multi-Media Keys
 
USB-C
 
USB-C
 
USB passthrough
 
USB passthrough
 
Connection
Wired, Wired only
Connection
Bluetooth, Wired, Wireless
Polling Rate
-
Polling Rate
1000 Hz
Battery capacity
-
Battery capacity
2000 mAh
Hall Effect Support
 
Hall Effect Support
 
QMK Support
 
QMK Support
 
VIA Support
 
VIA Support
 
VIAL Support
 
VIAL Support
 
N-Key Rollover
 
N-Key Rollover
 
Rapid Trigger
 
Rapid Trigger
 
Mount Style
-
Mount Style
Tray Mount
Screw in Stabilizers
 
Screw in Stabilizers
 
Sound Dampening
 
Sound Dampening
 
Backlight
 
Rgb
Backlight
 
Rgb, White, North-face
Case Colors
Case Colors
Case Material
Aluminum
Case Material
Aluminum, Plastic, ABS
Keycaps Material
PBT
Keycaps Material
PBT
Dimensions
41 x 442 x 132 mm
Dimensions
19 x 120 x 387 mm
Weight
1200g
Weight
679g
*Something incorrect or missing? Please
let me know
!

Pros and Trade-offs

Your primary need dictates the choice. If you work extensively with numbers, desire a specific themed look, and prefer a simple plug-and-play setup, the Akko 5108S is the straightforward option. If you value a clutter-free desk, need to switch between multiple devices, or want to deeply customize your typing experience and key mappings, the Keychron K17 Pro is the more versatile and modern keyboard. Consider the K17 Pro's lack of a numpad and the 5108S's lack of wireless connectivity as the fundamental trade-offs.

Akko 5108S

  • +Full 108-key layout with a dedicated numpad.
  • +Features themed, dye-sublimated PBT JDA profile keycaps for a unique aesthetic.
  • +Wired USB-C connection ensures consistent power and signal.
  • +Includes pre-lubed Akko Cream Yellow Pro linear switches.
  • +Hot-swappable PCB allows for switch changes without soldering.
  • −Wired-only connectivity limits placement flexibility.
  • −Heavier at 1200g, making it less portable.
  • −Lacks advanced programmability software like QMK or VIA.
  • −Full-size layout requires significant desk space.

Keychron K17 Pro

  • +Tri-mode connectivity with Bluetooth 5.1 for up to 3 devices and a 1000 Hz polling rate wired mode.
  • +Supports QMK and VIA for extensive key remapping and macro programming.
  • +Low-profile, 96% layout saves desk space and is more portable at 679g.
  • +Hot-swappable for Gateron/Keychron low-profile mechanical switches.
  • +Includes adjustable typing angles and redesigned stabilizers, according to the manufacturer.
  • −96% layout lacks a dedicated numpad, which some users require.
  • −Low-profile keycaps are not shine-through, limiting RGB visibility in dark settings per a user review.
  • −Switch compatibility is limited to specific low-profile mechanical switches.
  • −The case uses a combination of ABS plastic and aluminum, not a full aluminum case.

Which Keyboard Is Better for Your Needs?

The Keychron K17 Pro wins in more categories, particularly for programming, travel, and modding, due to its programmability, wireless design, and compact form. The Akko 5108S is the clear choice for content creators and users who rely on a full numpad and prefer a themed, fixed aesthetic. For office use, it's a tie, as the full-size layout battles the multi-device wireless convenience. Gamers may lean towards the K17 Pro for its specified polling rate and wireless option.

GamingKeychron K17 Pro
  • •The Keychron K17 Pro lists a 1000 Hz polling rate in wired mode for lower latency.
  • •Its wireless Bluetooth mode offers flexibility for couch or console gaming setups.
  • •The 96% layout saves desk space for larger mouse movements.
OfficeTie
  • •The Akko 5108S has a full numpad, beneficial for data entry.
  • •The Keychron K17 Pro connects to up to 3 devices via Bluetooth for multitasking between a laptop, phone, and tablet.
  • •Both offer Mac and Windows support and include multimedia keys.
ProgrammingKeychron K17 Pro
  • •The Keychron K17 Pro supports QMK and VIA for extensive key remapping and macro creation.
  • •Its compact 96% layout keeps essential keys while freeing up desk space.
  • •The manufacturer states it includes keycaps for both macOS and Windows layouts.
TravelKeychron K17 Pro
  • •The Keychron K17 Pro is significantly lighter at 679g versus 1200g.
  • •Its wireless Bluetooth capability removes the need for a cable connection.
  • •The 96% layout and low-profile design make it more compact and slim.
ModdingKeychron K17 Pro
  • •The Keychron K17 Pro supports QMK/VIA open-source firmware for deep software customization.
  • •It is hot-swappable and the vendor description details compatibility with Gateron and Keychron low-profile mechanical switches.
  • •The vendor page mentions redesigned stabilizers for less wobble on larger keys.
Content CreationAkko 5108S
  • •The Akko 5108S's full 108-key layout provides dedicated media and numpad keys for shortcut and numerical input.
  • •Its themed, dye-sublimated JDA profile keycaps offer a specific aesthetic for setup presentation.
  • •The wired-only connection provides a reliable, lag-free experience for timeline scrubbing.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Discover similar products

You might also like similar products in that price range:

96
$106
Keychron K10 HE Wireless Magnetic Switch Custom Keyboard ISO Layout Collection
Keychron K10 HE
100%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Wired,
RGB,
VIA,
QMK,
HE,
Rapid trigger,
Alu case,
Tray Mount

88
$85
Keychron K17 Max QMK Wireless Custom Mechanical Keyboard ISO Layout Collection
Keychron K17 Max
96%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Wired,
RGB/ White LEDs,
Knob,
VIA,
QMK,
Alu case,
PCB Mount

97
$99
Keychron V5 Max QMK Wireless Custom Mechanical Keyboard ISO Layout Collection
Keychron V5 Max
96%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Wired,
RGB,
Knob,
VIA,
QMK,
Gasket Mount

88
$69
Keychron K5 Pro QMK/VIA Wireless Custom Mechanical Keyboard ISO Layout Collection
Keychron K5 Pro
100%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Wired,
RGB/ White LEDs,
VIA,
QMK,
Alu case,
Tray Mount

96
$89
Keychron V6 Max QMK Wireless Custom Mechanical Keyboard ISO Layout Collection
Keychron V6 Max
100%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Wired,
RGB,
Knob,
VIA,
QMK,
Gasket Mount

86
$67
Keychron K1 Pro QMK/VIA Wireless Custom Mechanical Keyboard ISO Layout Collection
Keychron K1 Pro
80%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Wired,
RGB/ White LEDs,
VIA,
QMK,
Alu case,
Tray Mount

91
$84
Keychron K4 QMK Wireless Mechanical Keyboard (ISO Layout) - Version 3
Keychron K4 V3
96%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Wired,
RGB/ White LEDs,
VIA,
QMK,
Tray Mount

87
$67
Keychron K13 Pro QMK/VIA Wireless Custom Mechanical Keyboard ISO Layout Collection
Keychron K13 Pro
80%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Wired,
RGB/ White LEDs,
VIA,
QMK,
Alu case,
Tray Mount

93
$84
Keychron K10 QMK Wireless Mechanical Keyboard (ISO Layout) - Version 2
Keychron K10 V2
100%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Wired,
RGB/ White LEDs,
VIA,
QMK,
Alu case,
Tray Mount

92
$69
Keychron K4 Pro QMK/VIA Wireless Mechanical Keyboard
Keychron K4 Pro
96%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Wired,
RGB/ White LEDs,
VIA,
QMK,
Tray Mount