KeebFinder
Not sure which keyboard to choose? Try the Keyboard Finder now!

Compare KBDFans Athena 1800 vs Keychron Q12 Differences Side by Side

This comparison is for users deciding between two premium, wired 96% aluminum keyboards. The choice is difficult because both offer hot-swap PCBs, extensive programmability, and high-quality builds at a similar price point. The decision hinges on whether you prioritize the unique southpaw layout of the Q12 or the aesthetic customization and screen of the Athena 1800, alongside their different mounting styles.

84
Athena 1800
96
Keychron Q12 QMK Custom Mechanical Keyboard

Select a keyboard to compare

4.7 (17)
4.5 (18)
  • Released in 2025
  • Available in a 95% layout
  • Offers Normal ergonomics
  • Includes a Yes, LCD display
  • Supports VIAL configuration
  • Uses a Top Mount mounting style
  • Weighs about 3000 g
  • Offers Yes, Rgb RGB lighting
  • Released in 2023
  • Has Linear, Tactile, Clicky switch options
  • Available in a 96% layout
  • Offers Southpaw ergonomics
  • Comes with a knob
  • Includes a No display
  • Compatible with both Mac and Windows
  • Provides dedicated media keys
  • Supports QMK firmware
  • Supports VIA configuration
  • Includes screw-in stabilizers
  • Uses a Gasket Mount mounting style
  • Runs at a 1000 Hz polling rate
  • Weighs about 2491 g
  • Sized at 20 x 145 x 409 mm
  • Features PBT keycaps
  • Offers Yes, Rgb, South-face, Rgb South-face RGB lighting
Scores
  • Performance: 77.6
  • Build Quality: 78.3
  • Productivity: 83.5
  • Customizability: 82.6
  • Portability: 43.6
Scores
  • Performance: 73.3
  • Build Quality: 89.5
  • Productivity: 97.9
  • Customizability: 100
  • Portability: 46
Name
KBDFans Athena 1800
Name
Keychron Q12
Release year
2025
Release year
2023
Switch Options
-
Switch Options
Linear, Tactile, Clicky
Profile
Normal Profile
Profile
Normal Profile
Hot Swappable
 
Hot Swappable
 
Layout Size
95%, 100%, 96%
Layout Size
96%
Layout Standard
ANSI, ISO
Layout Standard
ANSI, ISO
Layout Ergonomics
Normal
Layout Ergonomics
Southpaw
Knob Support
 
Knob Support
 
Display Support
 
LCD
Display Support
 
Mac/Win Support
 
Mac/Win Support
 
Multi-Media Keys
 
Multi-Media Keys
 
USB-C
 
USB-C
 
USB passthrough
 
USB passthrough
 
Connection
Wired, Wired only
Connection
Wired, Wired only
Polling Rate
-
Polling Rate
1000 Hz
Battery capacity
-
Battery capacity
-
Hall Effect Support
 
Hall Effect Support
 
QMK Support
 
QMK Support
 
VIA Support
 
VIA Support
 
VIAL Support
 
VIAL Support
 
N-Key Rollover
 
N-Key Rollover
 
Rapid Trigger
 
Rapid Trigger
 
Mount Style
Top Mount
Mount Style
Gasket Mount
Screw in Stabilizers
 
Screw in Stabilizers
 
Sound Dampening
 
Sound Dampening
 
Backlight
 
Rgb
Backlight
 
Rgb, South-face
Case Colors
Case Colors
Case Material
Aluminum
Case Material
Aluminum
Keycaps Material
-
Keycaps Material
PBT
Dimensions
-
Dimensions
20 x 145 x 409 mm
Weight
3000g
Weight
2491g
*Something incorrect or missing? Please
let me know
!

Pros and Trade-offs

Select the Keychron Q12 if your priority is a unique, ergonomic layout that maximizes desk space for your mouse and you value a gasket-mounted typing feel with a programmable knob. Opt for the KBDFans Athena 1800 if you are a modding enthusiast who wants extensive material choices, values the inclusion of a customizable LCD screen, and prefers the acoustics of a top mount design. Both represent high-quality, customizable endpoints in the 96% keyboard category.

KBDFans Athena 1800

  • +Includes a customizable LCD screen that supports custom GIFs and system indicators.
  • +Offers extensive material customization with four plate options and three cover plate options.
  • +Comes as a comprehensive kit with foam, force break tape, and a silicone gasket set.
  • +Supports VIAL firmware for easy graphical key remapping.
  • +Features a unique aesthetic with an owl-themed backplate and internal toolpath engravings.
  • −Extremely heavy, especially with the stainless steel cover plate (approximately 3kg).
  • −Uses a top mount design, which typically provides a firmer feel than gasket mount.
  • −The vendor notes that the 'RAW' case finish may have visible cosmetic imperfections.

Keychron Q12

  • +Unique southpaw (left-side) numpad layout improves ergonomics and mouse space.
  • +Features a double gasket mount design for a softer, more cushioned typing feel.
  • +Includes a programmable aluminum knob and supports both QMK and VIA.
  • +Comes with pre-lubed Gateron G Pro switches and screw-in stabilizers in the assembled version.
  • +Explicitly lists a 1000 Hz polling rate and includes dedicated Mac/Windows keycaps.
  • −Lacks any screen or visual display for system information or customization.
  • −Only available with a steel plate, offering less acoustic variety than the Athena.
  • −The southpaw layout requires an adjustment period for users accustomed to standard layouts.

Which Keyboard Is Better for Your Needs?

The Keychron Q12 wins for office, programming, and content creation due to its innovative southpaw layout, programmable knob, and system-switching features. The KBDFans Athena 1800 is the stronger choice for modders, offering more material choices and included modding accessories. For gaming and travel, the keyboards are evenly matched, with neither being portable and both offering solid wired performance.

GamingTie
  • •Both are wired-only, eliminating wireless latency concerns.
  • •The Keychron Q12 lists a 1000 Hz polling rate, while the Athena's polling rate is not specified.
  • •The Athena 1800's top mount may offer a firmer typing feel preferred by some gamers.
OfficeKeychron Q12
  • •The Keychron Q12's southpaw layout frees up mouse space on the right for right-handed users.
  • •It includes dedicated Mac and Windows keycaps and a system toggle for seamless switching.
  • •The manufacturer states its double gasket design reduces acoustic resonance, which may be beneficial in shared spaces.
ProgrammingKeychron Q12
  • •The southpaw layout keeps the numpad accessible without moving the right hand from the mouse.
  • •It supports QMK and VIA for deep key remapping and macro creation.
  • •Includes a programmable aluminum knob for shortcuts like zoom or scrolling.
TravelTie
  • •Both are extremely heavy, wired-only keyboards not designed for portability (Athena ~3kg, Q12 ~2.5kg).
  • •Neither offers wireless connectivity or a battery.
  • •Their large 96% footprints require significant desk space.
ModdingKBDFans Athena 1800
  • •The Athena 1800 kit includes a foam kit and force break tape.
  • •It offers a choice of four plate materials (Aluminum, FR4, Polycarbonate, Carbon Fiber) and three cover plate materials (Stainless Steel, Brass, Carbon Fiber).
  • •Its PCB uses a magnetic connector and POGO pins for the LCD screen, facilitating disassembly.
Content CreationKeychron Q12
  • •The Keychron Q12's programmable knob can be mapped to media controls, brush size, or timeline scrubbing.
  • •The southpaw layout is advantageous for shortcut-heavy work with a mouse.
  • •QMK/VIA support allows for complex macros tailored to editing software.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Discover similar products

You might also like similar products in that price range:

95
$159
Keychron Q5 Pro QMK/VIA Wireless Custom Mechanical Keyboard
Keychron Q5 Pro
96%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Wired,
RGB,
Knob,
VIA,
QMK,
Alu case,
Gasket Mount

96
$149
Keychron Q3 Pro QMK/VIA Wireless Custom Mechanical Keyboard ISO Layout Collection
Keychron Q3 Pro
80%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Wired,
RGB,
Knob,
VIA,
QMK,
Alu case,
Gasket Mount

73
$129
Minilo
Varmilo Minilo
75%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Screen,
RGB,
Knob,
Gasket Mount

99
$129
Keychron K2 HE Wireless Magnetic Switch Custom Keyboard
Keychron K2 HE
75%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Wired,
RGB/ White LEDs,
Knob,
VIA,
QMK,
HE,
Rapid trigger,
Alu case,
Tray Mount

-28% off
94
$221$159
Keychron Q6 Pro QMK/VIA Wireless Custom Mechanical Keyboard ISO Layout Collection
Keychron Q6 Pro
100%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Wired,
RGB,
Knob,
VIA,
QMK,
Alu case,
Gasket Mount

96
$106
Keychron K10 HE Wireless Magnetic Switch Custom Keyboard ISO Layout Collection
Keychron K10 HE
100%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Wired,
RGB,
VIA,
QMK,
HE,
Rapid trigger,
Alu case,
Tray Mount

90
$124
FEKER Alice98 Wireless Mechanical Keyboard With LED Screen
Feker Alice98
98%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Screen,
RGB,
Knob,
VIA,
Gasket Mount

95
$149
Keychron Q1 Pro QMK/VIA Wireless Custom Mechanical Keyboard ISO Layout Collection
Keychron Q1 Pro
75%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Wired,
RGB,
Knob,
VIA,
QMK,
Alu case,
Gasket Mount

82
$109
Keydous NJ98 Hot-Swappable Display Screen with Knob Keyboard Kit
Keydous NJ98
98%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Screen,
RGB,
Knob,
Alu case

92
$114
Keychron V3 Ultra 8K Wireless Custom Mechanical Keyboard ISO Layout Collection
Keychron V3 Ultra
80%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Wired,
RGB/ White LEDs,
Knob,
VIA,
QMK,
Gasket Mount