Compare Cherry BCP Black Pie Linear vs HMX Siliworks X Sonja Linear Differences Side by Side

Explore the comprehensive side-by-side comparison of the Cherry BCP Black Pie Linear and HMX Siliworks X Sonja Linear and view their biggest differences. The detailed comparison table allows you to see all the essential features, specifications, and benefits of each switch at a glance. Whether you're looking for performance, value, or specific functionalities, this comparison tool helps you make an informed decision.

Model
	79	79	Select a switch to compare
Rating	0.0 stars (0 reviews)	0.0 stars (0 reviews)
Purchase Options
Main differences	Released in 2024 52g actuation force 63.5g bottom-out force 1.4mm pre-travel 3.5mm total travel POM, Dupont stem 20mm spring	Released in 2025 45g actuation force 52g bottom-out force 2mm pre-travel 3.9mm total travel POM stem 22mm spring
Score	Compared with medium linear switches Overall / Value:78.8 Materials:76.5 Finish:83.9	Compared with medium linear switches Overall / Value:78.9 Materials:76.5 Finish:83.9
Name	Name Cherry BCP Black Pie Linear	Name HMX Siliworks X Sonja Linear
Release year	Release year 2024	Release year 2025
Switch type	Switch type Linear	Switch type Linear
Factory lubed	Factory lubed	Factory lubed
Profile	Profile Standard profile	Profile Standard profile
Actuation force	Actuation force 52g	Actuation force 45g
Bottom out force	Bottom out force 63.5g	Bottom out force 52g
Pre travel	Pre travel 1.4mm	Pre travel 2mm
Total travel	Total travel 3.5mm	Total travel 3.9mm
Pins	Pins 5-Pin	Pins 5-Pin
Magnetic Hall Effect	Magnetic Hall Effect	Magnetic Hall Effect
Top Housing Material	Top Housing Material Nylon, PA66	Top Housing Material Nylon, PA66
Bottom Housing Material	Bottom Housing Material Nylon, PA66	Bottom Housing Material Nylon, PA66
Stem Material	Stem Material POM, Dupont	Stem Material POM
Sound profile	Sound profile High-Pitched	Sound profile High-Pitched
Spring type	Spring type Long	Spring type Long
Spring length	Spring length 20mm	Spring length 22mm
Double stage	Double stage	Double stage
Long pole	Long pole	Long pole
Dust proof	Dust proof	Dust proof
Water resistant	Water resistant	Water resistant
Weight	Weight -	Weight -