KeebFinder
Not sure which keyboard to choose? Try the Keyboard Finder now!

Compare Jamesdonkey A3 3.0 vs Keychron Q1 V1 Differences Side by Side

This comparison is for buyers deciding between two feature-rich 75% keyboards with gasket mounts and extensive programmability. The choice is difficult because both support QMK, hot-swapping, and include a knob, but they diverge sharply on core priorities. The Jamesdonkey A3 3.0 offers triple-mode wireless connectivity and a large battery, while the Keychron Q1 V1 provides a heavy, all-aluminum build with superior stabilizers and broader layout support. Your decision hinges on whether untethered use or a premium, mod-centric foundation matters more.

72
JAMESDONKEY A3 3.0 QMK Gasket Mechanical Keyboard
93
Keychron Q1 QMK Custom Mechanical Keyboard ISO Layout Collection - Version 1

Select a keyboard to compare

0.0 (0)
4.5 (1175)
  • Released in 2024
  • Built with the ANSI layout standard
  • Supports Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz, Wired, Wireless connectivity
  • Equipped with a 3750 mAh battery
  • Sized at 42 x 148 x 329 mm
  • Features PBT keycaps
  • Offers Yes, Rgb RGB lighting
  • Released in 2023
  • Has Linear, Tactile, Clicky switch options
  • Built with the ISO, JIS, ANSI layout standard
  • Connects via USB-C
  • Supports VIA configuration
  • Includes screw-in stabilizers
  • Supports Wired, Wired only connectivity
  • Runs at a 1000 Hz polling rate
  • Weighs about 1700 g
  • Sized at 22 x 145 x 328 mm
  • Made with a Aluminum case
  • Features ABS, PBT keycaps
  • Offers Yes, Rgb, South-face, Rgb South-face RGB lighting
Scores
  • Performance: 53.2
  • Build Quality: 60.4
  • Productivity: 80.1
  • Customizability: 82.5
  • Portability: 75.9
Scores
  • Performance: 72.7
  • Build Quality: 89.7
  • Productivity: 97.9
  • Customizability: 99.9
  • Portability: 64.8
Name
Jamesdonkey A3 3.0
Name
Keychron Q1 V1
Release year
2024
Release year
2023
Switch Options
-
Switch Options
Linear, Tactile, Clicky
Profile
Normal Profile
Profile
Normal Profile
Hot Swappable
 
Hot Swappable
 
Layout Size
75%
Layout Size
75%
Layout Standard
ANSI
Layout Standard
ISO, JIS, ANSI
Layout Ergonomics
Normal
Layout Ergonomics
Normal
Knob Support
 
Knob Support
 
Display Support
 
Display Support
 
Mac/Win Support
 
Mac/Win Support
 
Multi-Media Keys
 
Multi-Media Keys
 
USB-C
 
USB-C
 
USB passthrough
 
USB passthrough
 
Connection
Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz, Wired, Wireless
Connection
Wired, Wired only
Polling Rate
-
Polling Rate
1000 Hz
Battery capacity
3750 mAh
Battery capacity
-
Hall Effect Support
 
Hall Effect Support
 
QMK Support
 
QMK Support
 
VIA Support
 
VIA Support
 
VIAL Support
 
VIAL Support
 
N-Key Rollover
 
N-Key Rollover
 
Rapid Trigger
 
Rapid Trigger
 
Mount Style
Gasket Mount
Mount Style
Gasket Mount
Screw in Stabilizers
 
Screw in Stabilizers
 
Sound Dampening
 
Sound Dampening
 
Backlight
 
Rgb
Backlight
 
Rgb, South-face
Case Colors
Case Colors
Case Material
-
Case Material
Aluminum
Keycaps Material
PBT
Keycaps Material
ABS, PBT
Dimensions
42 x 148 x 329 mm
Dimensions
22 x 145 x 328 mm
Weight
-
Weight
1700g
*Something incorrect or missing? Please
let me know
!

Pros and Trade-offs

Your priority dictates the choice. If you need a single keyboard for a clean, wireless desk setup across multiple devices, the Jamesdonkey A3 3.0 is the practical option. If you view your keyboard as a long-term foundation for customization and value a premium, heavy metal build above all else, the Keychron Q1 V1 is the superior investment. For most users, the wireless flexibility of the A3 3.0 will be the more impactful daily feature.

Jamesdonkey A3 3.0

  • +Triple-mode connectivity with Bluetooth, 2.4GHz, and wired USB.
  • +Includes a large 3750mAh battery for wireless use.
  • +Features five-layered sound-absorbing padding for dampened acoustics.
  • +Uses OEM height PBT keycaps and comes with TTC Iron V2 switches pre-installed.
  • +Offers a web-based QMK driver for key programming without software installation.
  • −Construction materials are not specified as metal, suggesting a plastic case.
  • −Lacks the detailed modding support like screw-in stabilizers and plate choices found on the Q1.
  • −No vendor reviews are available to gauge real-world reliability.

Keychron Q1 V1

  • +Constructed with a full CNC machined 6063 aluminum body.
  • +Supports both QMK and VIA software for extensive programmability.
  • +Includes high-quality Gateron screw-in PCB stabilizers.
  • +Offers a choice of aluminum or steel plates and is available as a DIY kit.
  • +South-facing RGB LEDs prevent interference with Cherry or OEM profile keycaps.
  • −Wired-only connectivity, with no wireless or battery option.
  • −Very heavy at 1700g, making it less portable.
  • −The manufacturer notes some compatibility issues with MT3 and XDA profile keycaps.

Which Keyboard Is Better for Your Needs?

The Jamesdonkey A3 3.0 is the clear choice for mobile and wireless-centric uses like office work, travel, and gaming where low-latency wireless is valued. The Keychron Q1 V1 dominates for stationary, mod-focused scenarios like programming and keyboard customization, thanks to its metal construction and extensive hardware support. For content creation, both are equally capable due to shared features like the programmable knob and QMK.

GamingJamesdonkey A3 3.0
  • •The Jamesdonkey A3 3.0 offers a 2.4 GHz wireless mode with a manufacturer-claimed low-latency response.
  • •Its five-layered sound-absorbing padding may help reduce distracting noise during sessions.
  • •The Keychron Q1 V1 is wired-only, which may limit desk setup flexibility for some gamers.
OfficeJamesdonkey A3 3.0
  • •The Jamesdonkey A3 3.0 supports Bluetooth and 2.4 GHz wireless, making it easy to switch between devices.
  • •Its 3750mAh battery supports extended cordless use.
  • •It includes Mac and Windows support out of the box.
ProgrammingKeychron Q1 V1
  • •The Keychron Q1 V1 supports QMK and VIA software for deep, easy key remapping and macro creation.
  • •Its layout supports ANSI, ISO, and JIS standards, offering broader regional keycap compatibility.
  • •The included screw-in PCB stabilizers, according to the manufacturer, provide a more stable typing feel for large keys.
TravelJamesdonkey A3 3.0
  • •The Jamesdonkey A3 3.0 is wireless, eliminating the need to carry a cable.
  • •It has a smaller listed volume (329*148*42mm) compared to the Keychron's heavier 1700g weight.
  • •Its built-in battery allows for use without a direct power source.
ModdingKeychron Q1 V1
  • •The Keychron Q1 V1 has a full CNC machined aluminum case and offers a choice of aluminum or steel plates.
  • •It includes Gateron screw-in PCB stabilizers and supports third-party screw-in stabilizers.
  • •It is available as a DIY kit/barebones option for building from scratch.
  • •The manufacturer states the gasket design allows for up to 2.5mm of flex for tuning the typing feel.
Content CreationTie
  • •Both keyboards feature a programmable multimedia knob for controlling volume or other parameters.
  • •Both support QMK firmware for assigning macros and shortcuts to streamline workflows.
  • •Both offer RGB backlighting for visual customization.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Discover similar products

You might also like similar products in that price range:

98
$94
Keychron V1 Max QMK Wireless Custom Mechanical Keyboard ISO Layout Collection
Keychron V1 Max
75%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Wired,
RGB,
Knob,
VIA,
QMK,
Gasket Mount

95
$79
Keychron Q10 (Alice Layout) QMK Custom Mechanical Keyboard
Keychron Q10
75%,
Hotswap,
Wired,
RGB,
Knob,
VIA,
QMK,
Alu case,
Gasket Mount

94
$94
Keychron V3 Max QMK Wireless Custom Mechanical Keyboard ISO Layout Collection
Keychron V3 Max
80%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Wired,
RGB,
Knob,
VIA,
QMK,
Gasket Mount

95
$86
Keychron Q1 QMK Custom Mechanical Keyboard - Version 1
Keychron Q1
75%,
Hotswap,
Wired,
RGB,
Knob,
VIA,
QMK,
Alu case,
Gasket Mount

93
$97
Keychron V1 Ultra 8K Wireless Custom Mechanical Keyboard ISO Layout Collection
Keychron V1 Ultra
75%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Wired,
RGB/ White LEDs,
Knob,
VIA,
QMK,
Gasket Mount

94
$100
Keychron Q8 Pro (Alice Layout) QMK/VIA Wireless Custom Mechanical Keyboard
Keychron Q8 Pro
65%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Wired,
RGB,
Knob,
VIA,
QMK,
Alu case,
Gasket Mount

82
$41
JAMESDONKEY A3 Gasket Mechanical Keyboard
Jamesdonkey A3
75%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Wired,
RGB,
Knob,
Gasket Mount

95
$100
Keychron Q6 QMK Custom Mechanical Keyboard
Keychron Q6
100%,
Hotswap,
Wired,
RGB,
Knob,
VIA,
QMK,
Alu case,
Gasket Mount

93
$105
MonsGeek M1W Aluminum Wireless Gasket DIY Kit
Monsgeek M1W
75%,
Hotswap,
Wireless,
Wired,
RGB,
Knob,
VIA,
QMK,
Alu case,
Gasket Mount

95
$90
Keychron Q5 QMK Custom Mechanical Keyboard
Keychron Q5
96%,
Hotswap,
Wired,
RGB,
Knob,
VIA,
QMK,
Alu case,
Gasket Mount