Jamesdonkey S1 vs Machenike AIR50Aluminum or Hot-Swap
Choose the Jamesdonkey S1 for its aluminum case and sound-dampening details, or the Machenike AIR50 if hot-swappable switches and RGB lighting matter more.
KeebFinder may earn a commission when you buy through these links, at no extra cost to you.
Which one should you get?
Get the
Jamesdonkey S1
Battery
Build quality in the bottom 10% of 75% boards under $100.
- Aluminum case, compared with the AIR50's plastic case.
- Tactile Gateron 2.0 Brown low-profile switches.
- Vendor describes silicone padding between the plate, PCB and switches, plus EVA foam bottom padding.
- Switches are soldered. Swapping them means soldering.
- Low-profile switches and keycaps only. Standard MX keycaps will not fit.
Get the
Machenike AIR50
Hot-swappable
Build quality in the bottom 5% of 75% boards under $100.
- Hot-swappable sockets support switch replacement without soldering.
- Clicky and linear switch options are listed.
- RGB backlighting, with 20 lighting effects described by the vendor.
- Low-profile switches and keycaps only. Standard MX keycaps will not fit.
Pick the Jamesdonkey S1 if an aluminum case, tactile switches and the vendor-described silicone and EVA foam padding are your priorities. Choose the Machenike AIR50 if you want hot-swappable switches, RGB lighting or the lower listed weight. Check that any replacement switches or keycaps are low-profile for either keyboard.
The differences that matter
Skip the 40-row spec sheet. These are the specs that change how each board feels, sounds, and fits your desk.
Jamesdonkey S1
Machenike AIR50
Hot-swappable
No
Yes
Switch changes without soldering
Battery
2,000 mAh
1,600 mAh
A larger battery means fewer cables during the day
Case material
Aluminum
Plastic
Switch options
Tactile
Clicky, Linear
Weight
500 g
456 g
Heavier boards stay planted and lighter ones travel
- Jamesdonkey S1
- Machenike AIR50
- Performance
- 4948
- Build quality
- 4339
- Productivity
- 7156
- Customizability
- 4659
- Portability
- 7674
- Layout size: 75%
- Connection: Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz, Wired
- Low profile
- Keycaps: PBT
What will you mostly use it for?
The S1 edges ahead for office and programming setups where tactile switches and its described internal padding are appealing. The AIR50 is the more adaptable pick for switch changes and a colorful backlight, and its lower listed weight favors travel. Gaming is a close call because both have three connection modes, with distinct switch options and listed features. Both remain low-profile boards with restrictions on compatible switches and keycaps.
It's a tie
- Both provide Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz wireless and wired connectivity.
- The Jamesdonkey S1 has tactile switches, while the Machenike AIR50 is listed with clicky and linear switch options.
- The S1 lists N-Key Rollover; the AIR50 description lists adjustable feet.
Jamesdonkey S1 vs Machenike AIR50 specs
Every tracked spec, side by side. Rows marked with a dot differ between the boards.
9 of 19 specs differ
Jamesdonkey S1
Machenike AIR50
Switch options
Hot-swappable
Low profile
Sound dampening
Layout size
Layout standard
Ergonomics
Display
Connection
Battery
USB-C
Case material
Keycaps
Weight
Dimensions
Backlight
N-key rollover
Mac & Windows
Released
Compare prices
Live prices from the stores we track, cheapest in-stock offer first.
Prices in USD are converted to your currency and can change at any time. KeebFinder may earn a commission when you buy through these links, at no extra cost to you.
Lowest price across stores, Amazon excluded.
- Check on Amazon
Amazon
Check price
Jamesdonkey S1 vs Machenike AIR50: your questions
The Jamesdonkey S1 has an aluminum case, tactile switches and white backlighting. The Machenike AIR50 has a plastic case, hot-swappable sockets and RGB backlighting.
Yes, the AIR50 is listed with hot-swappable sockets, and its vendor description specifies full-key hot-swap support. The S1's switches are soldered, so replacing them requires soldering.
No, both keyboards are limited to low-profile keycaps, and standard MX keycaps will not fit. The same low-profile restriction applies to replacement switches.
The S1 has an aluminum case, while the AIR50 has a plastic case. Choose based on whether aluminum or plastic is your preferred case material.
The S1 is listed with white backlighting, not RGB. Its vendor description says the white backlight has 17 lighting modes.
The AIR50 vendor description lists RGB backlighting with 20 lighting effects. The S1 is described as having white backlighting with 17 modes.
The AIR50 weighs 456g, while the S1 weighs 500g. Both are low-profile 75% keyboards and support Bluetooth and 2.4 GHz wireless connections.
The S1 vendor description identifies Gateron 2.0 Brown low-profile tactile switches. Its compatibility rules state that the switches are soldered.
The AIR50 vendor description names Red linear and Blue clicky low-profile switch options. The product metadata also lists clicky and linear switch types.
Both list Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and wired connectivity. The S1 vendor description identifies its wired connection as USB, and the AIR50 vendor description identifies Bluetooth V5.0 and wired USB.
Both product listings specify Mac and Windows support. The AIR50 vendor description also mentions one-click switching between the two systems.
The S1 has a listed 2000mAh battery, compared with 1600mAh for the AIR50. The AIR50 vendor describes up to a week of battery life, but the S1 description does not give a specific runtime.
Not sold on either?
Still torn?
Answer a few quick questions and the keyboard finder ranks 2,000+ boards by how you will actually use yours.